Vital Signs: Psychological Responses to Ecological Crisis (Ed: Mary-Jayne Rust & Nick Totton, Published Karnac 2012)

Book review: Caroline Brazier

Perhaps one of the most exciting aspects of this time of planetary turmoil breakdown, despair and hope is that it confronts us so strongly with profound questions about what we are like as human beings[1]

The struggle to rectify our relationship with a failing environmental system provides humanity with perhaps the greatest challenge that it has yet to face. In recognising forces of destruction which have already been released through our collective action, we are both the implicated and the victims; perpetrators and powerless in a potential catastrophe. Making sense of this situation and finding a response to it faces us not only with difficult social and technical questions, but also, more significantly, with a struggle to make sense of our collective position, and even our humanity, which goes right to the core of our being. Ecological crisis brings into question our very nature as animals and as humans and throws into the spotlight the search for the meaning of life itself.

In such circumstances, psychotherapists, as facilitators of the exploration of personal meaning, seem bound to reflect upon the environmental context in which they, and their clients, operate. The increasing interest which some therapists are showing in environmentally based therapies and aligned areas of work is therefore particularly welcome. A growing movement of practitioners, who take the situation seriously enough that they can no longer divorce their conversations with individuals from the larger context of environmental change, is reflected in the recent publication of a collection of papers under the editorship of Mary-Jayne Rust and Nick Totton.

Vital Signs: Psychological Responses to Ecological Crisis is, as is purports to be, a collection of responses which speak from a variety of perspectives and voices. As such it reflects the breadth of the community who practice eco-psychology and environmental therapies. Among its contributors are writers and practitioners from a variety of related fields including psychotherapists, academics, educators, and those involved in practical activism. The book aims to represent the emerging British voice in the movement, but includes among its twenty chapters some papers which reflect work from the United States and mainland Europe. Whilst some chapters are written by people well known in the field, others come from relative newcomers and bring a taste of grass roots work and viewpoints.

With such a variety of material it is impossible to comment on every chapter, however in this review I would like to comment on some of the significant themes which emerge in the writing.

Many of the chapters, as one might expect, take their lead from the deep ecology movement, which grew out of the work of Arne Naess in the 1970s. For example, in chapter five and chapter eighteen, both written by Margaret Kerr and David Key, the writers draw strongly on his theory as a basis for their understanding of the unconscious process as it emerges in the Natural Change Project and other wilderness work which they conduct in the Scottish highlands. Naess is also referred to by both Rust and Totton in their respective chapters and the deep ecology movement of Naess and Macy is cited and clearly influential on many other writers in the book.

The deep ecology movement tends to view the way forward in terms of a reconnection with the natural and the wild through a spiritual, one might say mystical, expansion of the sense of self. According to such models, the way out of environmental crisis is through identification with the planet itself and a sense of interconnection with the bio-system as a whole. Another metaphor which is used to describe the planetary problems is that of sickness, and in chapter three, Gaia with AIDS, Peter Chatalos combines James Lovelock’s Gaia theory[2] with ideas drawn from Naess, suggesting that the reason why humans are failing to respond to the crisis as a part of a planetary self-healing system is because of this lack of identification with the whole. Human psychology differentiates and separates us from the rest of nature.

Many of the writers in the book thus explicitly or implicitly explore the philosophical basis of potential change. In addition to Chatalos, a  number of the writers see humans as being at the root of the ecological problem and advocate solutions which involve some sort of return to our wild, embodied nature, as for example Viola Samson in Chapter one. Such ideas of the wild are also found in chapters by Totton, Rust and Bradshaw.

Such perspectives often refer back to the Buddhist teaching of Interdependent Co-arising[3]. Such is the influence of Macy and others in the deep ecology movement that ideas of inter-connection and inter-being predominate in the thinking of many environmental theorists. I note, however, in passing, regret that theorists in this book have not drawn on the earlier Buddhist teaching of Dependant Origination which emphasises humans’ dependant nature rather than our inter-dependence[4]. As James Lovelock suggests in his Gaia hypothesis, the planet will survive without humans, albeit in an afflicted form but humans will not survive without the planet.

By contrast to ideas of a return to the natural, Paul Maitney’s chapter four, Longing to be Human provides a refreshing move away from the glorification of the wild, or return to Eden, pointing out that it is our animal instincts for consumption and greed which are at the root of environmental problems. In contrast to the popular ideas of connection to our animal nature, Maitney sees the human capacity for thought and spiritual insight as the source of any possible salvation for the planet and thus roots a possible future in our evolutionary capacity. In place of inter-dependence he advocates differentiation, and he supports the view that spiritual and religious values have always had an important place in the regulation of human society and the overcoming of instincts such as greed. Whether or not one agrees with this position, which stands out against the predominating culture of the book, this chapter particularly stimulating and well argued.

Consumerism and the emphasis on individualism understandably raise questions in a number of chapters. Many of these discussions are theoretical, but Rosemary Randall, in chapter seventeen, addresses these themes in practical ways by discussing how groups set up in Cambridge under the Carbon Conversations project challenged people to reduce their carbon footprint. Another practical example of environmentally based work is chapter eight by Inger Birkeland and Astri Aasen which beautifully describes their work with school children.

In a book on the relationship between psychotherapy and the environment, it is perhaps not surprising that one of the most exciting chapters is that of Nick Totton, who offers an analysis of therapeutic methodology based on his reflections on wildness. In this chapter Totton rejects the prevalent culture of outcome orientated therapy and proposes a non-interventive, meaning-making process. He proposes a model which, rather than regarding therapist and client as an isolated dyad, sees them as engaged in a shared process which is part of the greater system of human and non-human phenomena, and as such holds and works with aspects of the greater whole. The therapeutic relationship is itself an eco-system and is embedded within a greater eco-system.

The individual cannot exist or be understood without the group/s of which it is part; likewise the group cannot exist or be understood without the individuals who make it up.[5]  

Totton’s chapter proposes a reconsideration of many therapeutic expectations, such as the sanctity of the traditional therapeutic boundary and ideas of intentionality and control, in favour of a co-creative process in which shared encounter and exploration unfolds within an ambiance where no certainty of objectivity becomes possible because all positions are part of the whole. Such proposals have obvious critiques within the current therapy paradigm, but nevertheless hold an important counter-position which is potentially enriching and refreshing to the whole profession.

The final chapter of the book picks up this theme of the voice from the margins. Chris Robertson draws on Jerome Bernstein’s concept of borderland consciousness, presented in chapter fourteen, the consciousness which expresses itself through a special intimacy with the natural, the animal and the wild. In chapter twenty, Robertson explores ways in which the outsider and the marginal person may provide insight into the missing aspect of a situation. Echoing Totton’s questioning of the value of hard boundaries, he proposes that it is especially in these undefined areas at the margins of social groupings that borderland consciousness emerges, bringing new perspectives which have the potential to bridge the spaces between human society and the wider, stricken planet.

An anthology is always a mixed affair, like the box of assorted sweets there will always be some flavours more favoured than others, but in the varied range of styles and content of the chapters in this book there are many important views offered. The book touches both the experiential and the theoretical in equal measure so will appeal to people with different agendas, and it has sufficient fresh thinking to stimulate those seeking a more intellectual take on the subject without being overly academic. At the same time I felt that most of the chapters were an unpacking and illustration of perspectives which have been in play for some time. With the exceptions of those which I have highlighted, I felt the book did a good job of presenting the current status quo rather than extending it, but this said, much of the cutting edge work being described is practical and does not necessarily lend itself to verbal interpretation. As descriptions of encounters with the wild, they can at best be reportage after the event.

If the book gives hint of ways forward and new developments in thinking these probably come in the discussions of the role of the boundary and the consequent critique of modern notions of self-hood, independence and therapeutic purpose. These discussions informed by, but not beholden to, the ecological debate seem live and vigorous, and have the potential to revive some of the creative energy lost from the profession in recent decades. Whether this will improve our relationship with our planet we have yet to see, but one hopes it may.



[1] Hilary Prentice, chapter thirteen p 175

[2] Lovelock, J 1979 Gaia: A New Look At Life on Earth Oxford

[3] For example as quoted by Totton P261

[4] I have argued this point more fully in Brazier C 2007 The Other Buddhism O-Books

[5] p258

Views: 35

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Tariki Buddhist Therapists Forum to add comments!

Join Tariki Buddhist Therapists Forum

Contact Us

Tariki Trust
The Buddhist House
12 Coventry Rd
Narborough
LE 19 2GR

www.tarikitrust.org
www.buddhistpsychology.info

courses@tarikitrust.org

Like us on facebook http://www.facebook.com/pages/Tariki-Trust/216222195123878

TARIKI TRUST IS A REGISTERED CHARITY

If you would like to help support our work, you can do so by donating through paypal or by sending us your donation directly. We really appreciate your support.

Besides offering training and retreats, Tariki Trust is involved in chaplaincy, environmental action and community support. No one in Tariki is salaried and all work including teaching is voluntary or offered at rates which are well below the professional norms.

OBITUARY- PERRY ISODORE IGOE

Friends, family and loved ones: greetings, and thank you for joining us for this celebration of the life of Perry Isadore Igoe.

Though we gather here today, bound by sorrow and loss, we share a precious gift. We were all privileged to live a life that has been touched by Perry. He possessed a number of extraordinary gifts, which he shared with us freely. None of these gifts, however, are more remarkable than his capacity for love in its purest, most sincere, and honest form. Love for his adored wife, his beloved daughters, his precious friends, and for nature that surrounds us all, especially the life breathed into us by the trees.

Perry was born August 1st 1963 and was very premature so spent the first six weeks of his life in an incubator where he captured the hearts of the nurses and midwives with his cuteness. The trademark infectious Perry smile is well known by all his friends and family so without a doubt, even as a baby he could melt hearts.

Growing up, he went to school in Braintree in Essex, where he lived with his mum Carol, his younger sister Tracey, and older brother Wayne.

Perry was severely dyslexic, so, as a young man, in a very lean job market, he looked for a practical career. He joined the RAF at 16 and served with them for 17 years in Biggin Hill, Brize Norton, Germany, and the Falkland islands. Perry was a peace loving soul and had no desire to ever take up arms, harm, or kill anyone. Since however there had been no wars for a long time, it felt like a fairly safe career for a fit young man. It suited Perry who loved to be part of a team.

When he was 23, Perry managed to search for and finally find his father, Isadore Griffin, who was Black American, which led to several visits to his father in the USA.  Sadly his father also died at an early age a few years later. But Perry has continued to keep regularly in touch with the American side of his family – he was always telling Liz that one day soon they would go to visit, what he jokingly called, - ‘the dark side’!

Perry then worked in logistics and stores for the RAF and was promoted to corporal but, as the Cold War ended, promotions in the RAF were increasingly hard to come by. So after 17 years Perry took voluntary redundancy, left the RAF and went to work for Motorola in Swindon. He bought a house with his then wife, Carrie, and lived in it with his two daughters Sian & Kylie and rather a lot of strange pets. 

Perry was a great believer in investing in property and at one point when he found his work hours cut down, he took on two other jobs and bought a house in Avebury, which he rented out for a while. He later moved to Avebury with his wife Antoinette and ran a B&B there. 

Avebury was a spiritual home for Perry – he loved the standing stones and he enjoyed the succession of eccentric, visiting tourists interested in the stone circles as well as the many crop circles that pop up in Wiltshire fields in the spring and summer months. Whilst Perry was there he was a member of a Wiccan coven and later a shamanistic group.

In 2007 Perry decided to train as a counsellor with the Buddhist Organisation, the Amida Trust – now re-named - the Tariki Trust. This was where he met Liz and they became good friends.  In 2009 they both qualified as counsellors. In his usual ‘speedy’ fashion Perry had completed the course in record time – under 2 years. He went on to work for an organisation which helped educate young people with Autism and Asperger's Syndrome. Perry worked as a counsellor for several years before he finally fulfilled a life-long dream of buying a property ‘somewhere warm’.

In 2013 Perry moved again, lock stock and barrel, to the Serra De Estrella Mountains in Portugal where he quickly made a lot of friends among the ex-pats from the UK and Europe, all busy restoring old buildings and farming the land.

Perry and Liz met again accidentally in 2014 at the Buddhist House. They fell in love during a marathon 17.5 hour dinner and talked through the night and most of the following day. Since then Perry and Liz have been busy restoring their house in Portugal, affectionately named ‘The Ranch’ and have gone from having baths by candlelight in the goat shed, to a beautiful home with 3 bathrooms. Perry was never happier than when he was walking around the land working out watering systems and making sure the 150 trees he’d planted were growing well. Indicative of his altruistic personality and philosophy of sustainability, all the trees he planted at ‘The Ranch’ have been selected to provide for the next generations. A fan of tree nursing myself, I would often ask him about his trees and we would share videos and ideas for them. On a specific topic of his latest project, the Pecan trees, he mentioned how the earliest the small, 1-inch saplings would grow to bear fruit in 10 years, and it might be a good 20 before they reach maturity. “Perry,” I said, “that's ...a really long time.” To which he replied: “They aren't for me.”

And this is the type of person Perry was - always thinking of others first. Planning for the long term, working for a sustainable world, a world that works with nature, not against it. To paraphrase an ancient Greek proverb, “a wise man plants trees in whose shade he knows he will never sit.”

Perry had a great love of nature and the natural world, which he attributed to his Native American ancestors. His great love was trees, which he believed really spoke to him. So Perry returned to the Buddhist house to train in eco-therapy and shortly thereafter Perry and Liz started running eco-therapy and tree planting holidays in Portugal. Alongside his projects in Portugal, Perry joined several local eco-projects in Bristol.

On the 10th of July 2016, Perry and Liz married at Tortworth Court in Gloucestershire in a beautiful hand-fasting ceremony with over a 100 family and friends. Neither of them stopped smiling and laughing all day long, and Perry tore up the dance floor in what seemed like a union of John Travolta and Patrick Swayze. Since then they have spent six months of every year at the Ranch in Portugal and have welcomed many family and friends as visitors there.

Perry loved life – he just loved being here on this earth. Many people on this Earth believe in a higher power or greater purpose. Perry was content being himself, in this world, right now, enjoying the greatest and the smallest life has to offer. A true “Zen master”, as I like to describe him to my friends.

Perry was the most gentle and kindest of men – a true gentleman. Perry never had a bad word to say about anyone – not a criticism or judgement ever passed his lips. He didn’t swear, he didn’t argue, and he also didn’t drink alcohol, smoke, or even take tea or coffee. That is one reason why his death has been such a shock for all of us. Perry’s life was about love, acceptance, and working with others as part of a team, and he lived that out with every breath he took.

We have been lucky to know Perry in this life, we regret his passing on so soon, and so young, but his spirit and his legacy will remain among us – youthful, lively, fun, and full of love, and that oh-so-special smile.  We honour him.   

Blog Posts

One-day HUMANISTIC PSYCHOLOGY Conference Expanding a Humanistic Vision for a 21st Century Psychogy

One-day HUMANISTIC PSYCHOLOGY Conference

Expanding a Humanistic Vision for a 21st Century Psychology

Saturday 7th October 2017

Resources for London, 356 Holloway Road, London N7 6PA, 9am-5pm

Cost: £60 - includes lunch, refreshments and live music from

Jennifer Maidman and Annie Whitehead (ex Penguin Cafe…

Continue

Posted by caroline brazier on August 29, 2017 at 18:30

TARIKI ECOTHERAPY UPDATE

This is a newsletter for all those who have been involved with our Ten Directions ecotherapy training, including past and current students and people who are considering joining the programme in 2017. Within Tariki we have a growing community of people who share an interest in taking therapeutic work outdoors and we want to keep you in touch with us and with one…

Continue

Posted by caroline brazier on March 24, 2017 at 20:32

Grounded in Faith: Psychotherapy and Pureland - paper presented at European Shin Conference 2012

Grounded in Faith: Psychotherapy and Pureland

Since the time of the Buddha people have looked to Buddhism as a source of salvation from their unhappiness and confusion. In the modern age, psychotherapy has become a route which many people choose to help them face and move beyond their personal suffering. Not surprisingly many Western therapists tend to gravitate towards Buddhist ideas and, conversely, Buddhists are often interested in exploring how their faith…

Continue

Posted by caroline brazier on September 4, 2012 at 14:35

Running Tide Article

I wrote this article for Running Tide back in January but it didnt get published and as Running Tide has only just come out, things had obviously moved on. I'm putting it up here because it seems like a pity to waste a good article - or even a mediocre one!

 

Going Back to Go Forward: The Birth of Tariki Trust

How often do you wish you could go…

Continue

Posted by caroline brazier on March 13, 2012 at 22:49 — 4 Comments

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2021   Created by caroline brazier.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service